8 Creamy Shrimp Dinners
Bread is non-negotiable whenever I make creamy shrimp, because leaving any of that sauce in the pan feels like a waste.
Shrimp cook fast and a cream sauce only needs a short simmer, so most of these are ready in fifteen to twenty-five minutes.
The exception is the creamy shrimp enchiladas at the end, which take a little over an hour and are worth saving for a slower evening.
The sauces go from garlic parmesan and Cajun to lemon, coconut milk, mushroom and a classic shrimp Newburg made with sherry.
1. Creamy Garlic Shrimp with Parmesan
A pound of shrimp in a buttery sauce of six garlic cloves, white wine or chicken broth, a cup and a half of reduced fat cream and freshly grated parmesan, with fresh parsley.
Twenty minutes.
Use chicken broth instead of wine if you’d rather not open a bottle for half a cup.
2. Creamy Cajun Shrimp
A pound of shrimp in a Cajun tomato cream sauce made with butter, garlic, white wine, tomatoes, Cajun seasoning and a cup of heavy cream, with scallions and parsley.
Twenty minutes, four servings.
It’s meant to be piled onto a bed of rice, which soaks up the spicy sauce.
3. Creamy Lemon Garlic Shrimp
A pound and a half of large shrimp simmered in a lemon garlic parmesan sauce, made with butter, lemon juice and zest, and half and half thickened with a little flour.
Fifteen minutes, six servings.
Zest the lemon before you cut it, because a squeezed half is much harder to zest.
4. Garlic Shrimp in Coconut Milk
Shrimp in a sauce of onion, garlic, a can of full-fat coconut milk, fish sauce, honey and lime juice, with sweet paprika, chili flakes and cilantro.
Two teaspoons of cornstarch thicken the sauce.
Twenty minutes, four servings.
Stick with full-fat coconut milk as the recipe says, because light coconut milk makes a thin sauce.
5. Shrimp and Spinach in Cream Sauce
Shrimp and spinach in a cream sauce with butter, onion, garlic powder, thyme, parsley and lemon juice.
The site describes it as a quick, low-carb shrimp dinner.
Twenty-five minutes, five servings.
Spinach shrinks a lot as it wilts, so a pile that looks like too much will cook down to the right amount.
6. Shrimp Newburg
Tender shrimp in a creamy sauce of butter, sherry and whole milk, thickened with flour.
Newburg is an old-school seafood dish, and this version is made with milk instead of heavy cream.
Fifteen minutes, four servings.
Spoon it over rice or toast, which is how Newburg is usually served.
7. Creamy Mushroom Shrimp
Shrimp and fourteen ounces of mushrooms in an Alfredo-style sauce of heavy cream, parmesan and six cloves of garlic.
Sweet paprika, Italian seasoning and chili flakes season it, and parsley goes in too.
Twenty minutes, four servings.
Give the mushrooms room in the pan so they brown instead of steaming.
8. Creamy Shrimp Enchiladas
Flour tortillas filled with cilantro lime rice, a Creole-seasoned shrimp filling and pico de gallo, then topped with a cheese sauce.
Mozzarella and a cup of sour cream are both on the ingredient list.
An hour and five minutes, four servings.
It’s the one weekend project here, with thirty minutes of prep before the cooking starts.
Tips for Creamy Shrimp
Shrimp turn rubbery fast, so take them off the heat as soon as they’re pink and opaque.
Keep the heat low once the cream goes in, because a hard boil can make the sauce separate.
Thaw frozen shrimp in a bowl of cold water and pat them dry, so they don’t water down the sauce.
Parmesan melts more smoothly when it’s freshly grated than when it comes from a shaker.
Notes on Leftovers
Cooked shrimp in a cream sauce keeps three to four days in the fridge.
Reheat it gently over low heat with a splash of milk or broth, and stop as soon as it’s warm so the shrimp don’t toughen.
For more shrimp dinners, try these takeout-style shrimp dinners or these shrimp soups and stews.